Showing posts with label Common Sense. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Common Sense. Show all posts

Tuesday, October 20, 2015

Licensing guns like cars

There are a lot of people ignorantly re-posting a meme about licensing guns like cars. In some ways, many of us in the know would say, "Hey, that's a great idea!"

After all you can:

-Drive a car in public by yourself at 16
-Buy any car you can afford at 18
-Drive anything you want, as fast as you want on your own property with or without a license or training
-No federal license required
-You don't have to register a vehicle that stays on your own property
-You don't need a background check to buy a car
-You can buy a car in another state
-Car Mufflers are mandatory in public
-Car dealers don't have to get both a federal car dealers license AND a state/local business license
-Every state must recognize the license of any state, or even international licenses
-You only lose your license to drive based upon driving offenses, not random lists of other actions, misdemeanors, and long-ago mis-judgements. Even felons who used a get-away car aren't banned from driving for LIFE.
-If you lose your driver's license, you can still drive a farm vehicle on private property.
-There are hardship exemptions for people who need vehicles in remote areas that allow for underage or otherwise ineligible people to drive

But, they'll say: "You have to get trained to be in public, and pass a test. You have to carry insurance. There are rules of the road to adhere to."

Well, yes. Particularly if you're going to drive/shoot professionally for pay, I would agree to mandatory minimum proficiency standards. And when it comes to the "rules of the road" for guns, I submit that the pro-gun crowd is far more qualified to comment than the anti-gun crowd.

And mandatory insurance has its pitfalls when trying to actually make an equitable system rather than simply implementing a barrier. Besides, in most states, you can carry a bond rather than insurance. But what we're really talking about there is a barrier, not a remedy for negative externality, because the externality is really being imposed by criminals, not by the law-abiding, so mandatory insurance would not solve anything.


Saturday, September 26, 2015

Ramifications

Whenever one examines a proposal to make a law, there should be a certain amount of diligent thought put into it.

Some easy things to ask oneself are:

-Is the bill complete in examining possible scenarios?
-Does the bill violate other established principles of the law, law enforcement, or the Constitution?
-Is the proposed law physically possible to enforce evenly and equally?
-Does the law disproportionately affect some group that happens to be out of favour at the moment?
-Does the law have a reasonably good chance of being effective, or is it just a fig leaf?

If a law cannot be effectively enforced, it undermines (bit by bit) the entire concept of law. Much like a principle of military leadership is "never give an order you KNOW will not be obeyed" because it makes you look weak and ineffective, and undermines belief in your leadership, a law that has no chance of being enforced more than sporadically undermines respect for the law and the rational and consistent culture of being "law-abiding".

Consider Virginia Senator Kaine's “Responsible Transfer of Firearms Act.” Here's a proposal that ignores existing laws and their problems, is only selectively enforceable, and has no clear definitions or metrics, which makes it easily subject to abuse by people who simply don't want you to have guns. This is not accidental. It's a deliberate tool used by both sides of the major political parties to ratchet up control. If the goalpost is vague, it's much easier to move it later.

Write your legislator.